Decolonization(s) and Education. Daniel Maul

societies are the result of the poor colonial education whose atavism is still a heavy burden for us. To point out the defects of that education, to instill the youth with the conscious of them in the classrooms, to show them that intellectual laziness is overwhelming us and that the lack of ideals condemns us to be a people without energies is to advance the work of diffusion aimed at a better destiny.”⁵⁹

      On the whole, “colonial education” became a quite effective means of legitimating one’s position in the political arena in the post-colonial setting, and even was invoked to justify plans for “colonization” of the land in the work of some advocates of free market and “re-education” through transformation of the population by immigration. Lastly, it also acted as a historiographical recurrent motive in the major task of attaching meanings to the past, colonial and post-colonial.

      Outlook: ‘Colonial Education’ and the construction of legitimacy in decolonization settings

      A preliminary assessment of the discourse about ‘colonial education’ should take into account the widespread presence of this motive in political, scholarly and – probably – educational settings. There is no doubt that this reference suited the ideological needs of the elites of the fragile polities of early post-independence Latin America very well. They looked back to the colonial past and considered that the central problems of their polities were the outcome of deep, historical causation. They partly indulged in their political judgements by considering ←36 | 37→the heavy inheritance of the habits produced by colonial education. Realities in Latin America, even in the early twentieth century, may not have been rosy and hopeful. The legitimacy of independence, republicanism and democracy was by no means affected by these disappointments. In this sense, colonial education as a discourse of seemingly consistent contours and functions, embraced equally by liberals, conservatives and later socialists, constituted a convenient resource for facing difficult realities.

In this sense, Latin American decolonization inaugurated a pattern of argument, in which the legitimacy of new political orders was strongly construed on the basis of historical insights. In cases, in which legitimacy is contested or fragile, actors may look for an ‘outside’ from which they borrow arguments that lend them additional meanings for constructing legitimacy. This operation, called externalization in the sociology of knowledge,⁶⁰ may refer to many sources. Actors may hint to experiences in other, more ‘advanced’ countries; they may refer to science or moral principles as well; or they may refer to history. Interestingly enough, decolonization processes favored a pattern of externalization in which references to the past, or to history gained a very significant place. Whether this constant referencing to the colonial past is a gain or a trap has worried several authors and intellectuals since independence. Yet the particular setting of decolonizing political and educational regimes in Latin America seems to have favored a strong historicizing gaze that eventually reached schools and became one of the elements in Latin American common sense discourses that definitely surfaced during the commemoration of the 500 years of the ‘discovery’ of the continent in 1992.

      Literature

      Aguirre Cinta, Rafael. Lecciones de Historia General de Guatemala. Guatemala: Impreto en la tipografía nacional, 1899.

      Alberdi, Juan Bautista. Elementos del derecho publico provincial, para la Republica Arjentina. Valparaiso: Imprenta del Mercurio, 1853.

      Ancona, Eligio. Historia de Yucatán desde la época más remota hasta nuestros días. Vol. II, Mérida: Imprenta de M. Heredia Argüelles, 1878.

      ←37 | 38→

      Baeza Ruz, Andrés. “Enlightenment, Education, and the Republican Project: Chile’s Instituto Nacional (1810–1830).” Paedagogica Historica 46, no. 4 (2010): 479–493.

      Baralt, Rafael María. Resúmen de la historia de Venezuela. Paris: Imprenta de H. Fournier y Comp., 1841.

      Barreda Laos, Felipe. Vida intelectual de la colonia (educación, filosofía y ciencias). Ensayo histórico crítico. Lima: Impr. “La industria”, 1909.

      Barros Grez, Daniel. Pipiolos i Pelucones. Tradiciones de ahora cuarenta años. Santiago: Imprenta Franklin, 1876.

      Bayly, Christopher Alan. The Birth of the Modern World, 1780–1914. Malden/Mass.: Blackwell, 2004.

      Baz, Gustavo, and Eduardo L. Gallo. Historia del ferrocarril mexicano. Mexico: Gallo y Compañía, 1874.

      Bilbao, Manuel. Historia de Rosas. Vol. I, Buenos Aires: Imprenta ‘Buenos Aires’, 1868.

      Bolívar, Simón. Speech of his Excellency General Bolivar at the Installation of the Congress of Venezuela in Angostura, on the 15th day of February 1819. Angostura: Printed by Andrew Roderick, 1819.

      Bushnell, David. Simón Bolívar. Hombre de Caracas, proyecto de América. Una biografía. Historias americanas, edited by Carlos Mayo. Buenos Aires: Biblos, 2002.

      Caruso, Marcelo. “New Schooling and the Invention of a Political Culture: Community, Rituals and Meritocracy in Colombian Monitorial Schools, 1821–1842.” In Imported Modernity in Post-Colonial State Formation, edited by Marcelo Caruso and Eugenia Roldán Vera. 277–306. Frankfurt: Peter Lang, 2007.

      Caruso, Marcelo. “Independencias latinoamericanas y escuelas mutuas: Un análisis desde la perspectiva de la historia global (ca. 1815–1850).” In História e Historiografia da Educação Ibero-Americana. Projetos, Sujeitos e Práticas, edited by Claudia Alves and Ana Chrystina Mignot. 19–42. Rio de Janeiro: Quartet, 2010.

      Caruso, Marcelo. “Emotional Regimes and School Policy in Colombia, 1800–1835.” In Childhood, Youth and Emotions in Modern History, edited by Stephanie Olsen. 73–94. New York: Palgrave, 2015.

      Caruso, Marcelo, and Eugenia Roldán Vera. “El impacto de las nuevas sociabilidaes: Sociedad civil, recursividad comunicativa y cambio educativo en la Hispanoamérica postcolonial.” Revista Brasileira de história da educação 11, no. 2 (2011): 15–52.

      ←38 | 39→

      de Pascual, Antonio Isidoro. Apuntes para la historia de la República Oriental del Uruguay desde el año 1810 hasta el de 1859. Vol. II, Paris: T. Ducessois, 1864.

      del Valle, José Cecilio. Obra escogida. Caracas: Biblioteca Ayacucho, 1982.

      Esposicion que el Secretario de Estado del Depacho de Interior de la República de Colombia hace al congreso de 1826 sobre los negocios de su departamento. Bogotá: Imp. de Manuel M. Viller-Calderon, 1826.

      Estrada, José Manuel. Lecciones sobre la historia de la República Argentina dadas públicamente en 1868. Buenos Aires: Librería del Colegio, 1898.

      Fonseca, Juan. “ ‘Sin educación no hay sociedad’: las escuelas lancasterianas y la educación primaria en los inicios de la república (1822–1826).” In La Independencia en el Perú. De los Borbones a Bolívar, edited by Scarlett O’Phelan Godoy. 265–288. Lima: Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú, 2001.

      Frontaura Arana, José Manuel. Noticias históricas sobre las escuelas públicas de Chile á fines de la era colonial. Santiago de Chile: Imprenta Nacional, 1892.

      García del Río, Juan. “Revista del estado anterior y actual de la instruccion publica en la America antes española.” El repertorio americano I (1826): 231–253.

      Gartz, Jochen. Liberale Illusionen. Unabhängigkeit und republikanischer Staatsbildungsprozeß im nördlichen Südamerika unter Simón Bolívar im Spiegel der deutschen Publizistik des Vormärz. Frankfurt: Peter Lang, 1998.

      Gorriti, Juan Ignacio. Reflecciones sobre las causas morales de las convulsiones interiores en los nuevos estados americanos y examen de los medios eficaces para reprimirlas. Valparaíso: Imprenta del Mercurio, 1836.

      Groot, José Manuel. Historia eclesiástica y civil de Nueva Granada. Vol. V, Bogotá: Casa Editorial de M. Rivas, 1893.

      Guenot, Estevan. Plan de