A Practical Discourse on Some Principles of Hymn-Singing. Bridges Robert

in his church but what would satisfy the highest artistic sense of the day, his answer is the same: he will tell you that it would be casting pearls before swine; and that unless the music is 'tuney' and 'catchy' the people will not take to it. And we cannot hastily dismiss these practical objections. The very Ambrosian music which is now so strange to modern ears was doubtless, when St. Ambrose introduced it, much akin to the secular music of the day, if it was not directly borrowed from it: and the history of hymn-music is a history of the adaptations of profane successes in the art to the uses of the Church. Nor do I see that it can ever be otherwise, for the highest music demands a supernatural material; so that it would seem an equal folly for musicians to neglect the unique opportunity which religion offers them, and for religion to refuse the best productions of human art. And we must also remember that the art of the time, whether it be bad or good, has a much more living relation to the generation which is producing it, and exerts a more powerful influence upon it, than the art of any time that is past and gone. It is the same in all aspects of life: it is the book of the day, the hero or statesman of the hour, the newest hope, the latest flash of scientific light, which attracts the people. And it must be, on the face of it, true that any artist who becomes widely popular must have hit off, 'I know not by what secret familiarity,' the exact fashion or caprice of the current taste of his own generation.

      1

      Confess. ix. 6.

      2

      Ibid. ix. 7.

      3

      This is perhaps rather a quality proper to the sensat

1

Confess. ix. 6.

2

Ibid. ix. 7.

3

This is perhaps rather a quality proper to the sensation.

4

'Et vix eis praebeo congruentem [locum].' which might only mean 'I cannot find the right place for them.'

5

Confess. x. 13.

6

St. Augustin does not allow that a vague emotion can be religious; it must be directed. Few would agree to this.