Embryogeny and Phylogeny of the Human Posture 2. Anne Dambricourt Malasse

247

      246 248

      247 249

      248 250

      249 251

      250  253

      251 254

      252  255

       Comparative Anatomy and Posture of Animal and Human Set

      coordinated by

      Djillali Hadjouis

      Volume 4

      Embryogeny and Phylogeny of the Human Posture 2

       A New Glance at the Future of our Species

      Anne Dambricourt Malassé

      First published 2021 in Great Britain and the United States by ISTE Ltd and John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

      Apart from any fair dealing for the purposes of research or private study, or criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, this publication may only be reproduced, stored or transmitted, in any form or by any means, with the prior permission in writing of the publishers, or in the case of reprographic reproduction in accordance with the terms and licenses issued by the CLA. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside these terms should be sent to the publishers at the undermentioned address:

      ISTE Ltd

      27-37 St George’s Road

      London SW19 4EU

      UK

       www.iste.co.uk

      John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

      111 River Street

      Hoboken, NJ 07030

      USA

       www.wiley.com

      © ISTE Ltd 2021

      The rights of Anne Dambricourt Malassé to be identified as the author of this work have been asserted by her in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.

      Library of Congress Control Number: 2021938413

      British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data

      A CIP record for this book is available from the British Library

      ISBN 978-1-78630-729-3

      1

      The 20th Century. A New Science: Human Paleontology

      1.1. Introduction

      The 19th century saw the recognition of the animal and simian origin of Homo sapiens, although not without difficulty, through thought experiments due to the lack of sufficient knowledge in both paleontology and reproductive biology. The long geological periods throughout the history of the Earth and its cooling, as described by Georges Buffon, made it possible to locate fossil and current species according to lineages, or phylums, and then to link these phylums together by looking for “intermediate” fossil species. In this phylogeny of multicellular organisms, which became vertebrates with the horizontal organization of chordates, the primate lineage can be distinguished by the verticalization of the neuraxis starting from the posterior cranial base, the reduction of prognathism and an encephalization that led to Homo sapiens, the most verticalized chordate. Verticalization was the guiding thread of the problem, and the bimania (meaning two-hands in Latin) linked to this verticality was then much more significant for anthropologists, along with encephalization, then bipedalism, which was not original, being common in gibbons as well as birds. Whatever one’s opinion on the meaning of Man’s place in the animal kingdom and the history of the Earth, verticalized anatomy has not left the place assigned to it by the history of animals since Aristotle. It remains the last point on the curve of this complexification/verticalization, which was accompanied by an increase in cognitive capacities.

For prehistorians and anthropologists, Homo sapiens is characterized by articulated language and symbolic behaviors manifested by the creation of objects unrelated to primary necessities. These activities concern ornaments, engravings, paintings and sculptures; as innovations that express values, significations, they are bearers of meaning. On the eve of 19th century, the oldest Homo sapiens skeletons were still rare, but they were already associated with these productions at prehistoric periods that had nothing in common with the Adamic tradition, still well anchored in the European culture that refused the idea of a simian origin. This filiation was defended at the Muséum national d’Histoire naturelle (French National Museum of Natural History, henceforth referred to as the Muséum) in 1802 by Jean-Baptiste Lamarck, Etienne Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire and his son Isidore Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire, but 70 years later, it did not find unanimous acceptance with an interesting and strong personality, the geophysicist, physician and anthropologist Armand de Quatrefages.

1.2. Human paleontology, a nascent science

      A new prehistoric Homo sapiens skeleton was exhumed in 1872 on the lands of the Principality of Monaco, in Cavillon, in one of the Grimaldi caves. Everything pointed to a sepulchral context at levels as old as the Cro-Magnon shelter in Les Eyzies-de-Tayac (France), dating back nearly 30,000 years. The stakes were considerable because the remains carried a mantilla composed of more than 200 shells on its head, covered with red ochre and black hematite. The discovery attested to an already highly ritualized and symbolic relationship with death. The mastery of articulated language left little room for doubt. The excavations, however, did not have any means of guaranteeing its date. Prehistory was not yet a scientific discipline.

      Armand de Quatrefages studied the Les Eyzies skeletons with his naturalist assistant, the doctor Ernest Hamy (1842–1902). Together they defined the Cro-Magnon race as “the second fossilized human race”, the first being the “Canstadt race” or Neanderthal Man, which was limited to three specimens recognized as: Neanderthal, Gibraltar and La Naulette (see Volume 1). Their study was exocranial, the base of the skull was partially preserved on one of the three adult skulls, but its endocranial surface was not described because of its inaccessibility and there was no question of damaging the unique piece.

      New fossils of European Neanderthals enriched the collections in 1886, with three individuals discovered in Belgium in the Spy cave (currently dated at 38,500 years) and especially in Croatia in 1899 in the Krapina cave, with nearly 900 fragmented human remains, nearly 80 individuals dated at 125,000 years old. Traces of anthropophagy would be confirmed.

The great novelty came from Asia with the discovery of fossils of monkeys and great apes, and above all that of a very ancient anthropomorph in Java which generated a great stir among anthropologists. The monkey fossils were collected in the powerful sedimentary deposits of the upper Indus basin called Siwaliks, composed of molasse deposited in the plain by the erosion of the Himalayan range during formation. In the northwestern Indian subcontinent, the deposits were slightly folded and formed the Potwar Plateau. The erosion and scarcity of vegetation gave access to numerous fossiliferous outcrops. Further east, these deposits formed the foothills of the Himalayas, strongly compressed by plate tectonics between India and Asia, sometimes to verticality. The outcrops became long narrow bands covered by tropical forest at low altitude and richer in thorny