«Оптимизация» высшего образования в России: преподаватели вузов и их классовый профсоюз «Университетская солидарность». Давид Мандель

Читать онлайн.



Скачать книгу

politique. № 6. 2016. стр. 925.

      30

      Kurilla I. «Education Reform in Russia». Russian Analytical Digest. №. 137. 2013. стр. 2.

      31

      Altbach P.G. и др. (ред.) Paying the Professoriate a Global Comparison of Compensation and Contracts. Hoboken. 2012. стр.30. Borovskaya M.A. и др. “Higher Education Institute Salary System as a Factor of Modernization of Education and Science in Russia”. World Applied Sciences Journal. № 30 (11). 2014. стр. 1678, 1680.

      32

      Добрынин С. «Ортогональный Физтех». Радио Свобода. 6 декабря. 2015. https://inosmi.ru/science/20151206/234702542.html Международное сравнение зарплат ППС вузов 29 стран показало, что зарплаты в России – одни из самых низких, см. Altbach P. и др. Paying the Professoriate. Routeledge. 2012.

      33

      «В Москве обсудили финансовую политику образования и науки». https://минобрнауки. рф/пресс-центр/11685.

      34

      Forrat. Там же. стр. 26.

      35

      O «новой государственной администрации» в российских вузах, см. Sigman С. «La montee de TElat-entrepreneur de 1'enseignement superieur’ et 1'hybridation public-prive: 1'exemple de la Russie». Economies etsocietes, Cahiers de I’ISMEA. XLIV № 4. 2010. стр. 581–602.

/9j/4AAQSkZJRgABAQEASABIAAD/2wBDAAMCAgMCAgMDAgMDAwMDBAcFBAQEBAkGBwUHCgkLCwoJCgoMDREODAwQDAoKDhQPEBESExMTCw4UFhQSFhESExL/2wBDAQMDAwQEBAgFBQgSDAoMEhISEhISEhISEhISEhISEhISEhISEhISEhISEhISEhISEhISEhISEhISEhISEhISEhL/wgARCAf9BdwDAREAAhEBAxEB/8QAHQAAAAcBAQEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAECAwQFBwYICf/EABoBAAMBAQEBAAAAAAAAAAAAAAABAgMEBQb/2gAMAwEAAhADEAAAAcg5PoQAAAAAAAADsb5dg6PHaSs1uUVmnH9KhdWud/zfT7eZWNXNQpaWDIZLwnFQFUOOcmqxHPTXEcvsMLU0A0cVqnVc6GICUqMbi0XOqyyAiSGioIkDcVmqJgSMQGYwBAQgCgAJACDEia14PSvoeDO15FzRgTlNI0AYQaoqlKvi+P08U4/eMs01qwMAYBBoMCAgMA2TRAAAgI0GMkjAATZNgABgBJUipComE004vN/I3nu8l54uAsZgAJMxExI2RNiVGmRcvq8Jz+uqbAwCkzKAAAAAAQAQANBMmEQAMYEBgABEgCANEAADBJMITFcvUb+TtHZwWioCDRsSwpZgQjc0yLc2U8jm/O/B71fmu938y0rJmh5V5fx9kAAAAAAAAA6uufY9vHhEWh0WC1y/i+mamti9D56V0eX2CfHKejFX1PHJV9Ooi31VmtHxoR1s1iHH9AxPS9GwLAAQACAgMxgFJKQQyYASwAEKAAAAEAGaowAEwCMABCIRjS0zrwekfQ8Cz24lRZgKlLQAJkAllclGvD8Xp4xy/QOTZlLVkMmGBoMCEACAwhk0BAkhGAADNMIAEwNESaQGCgMMAEAIYvK928fe+/xZtwaAqDFJACAhk0apLkKsU4fa4jm9lSoDIRgAAGAADCRMAiYQjQBgAAADMAAAgMAMAYEAAhE0h5NvLoejxtp7/Lu5tukbRgAKWEKFWA+4kGhOERtgfn+/JjLQurzYah1y878m4eyAAAAAAAAAdRfLufR5TQ5tZRserMuL2WbXQ9fk2+vJGSrlpdBYUVbrVqVoKU4aaMDl8vjvh/D9ExPUtUANUBgkxmgmAAAEBhAGAUIAAAzGAAJAhLTAgNLkDMQGBmUEE4RryekvQ+bna8iiSWgaFSACZIAwIp14jl78V4/on4sLYyTKDRAQgMxpYEGw0AQEBkMAAJoJAAAAAGjQTYGBhBiBKQZvO+28be/Q8SZUAkABmAAATCA5sNBGN8Pv8Dy+staAlIGAAmAAATAAYEGEICIDACAwMAQgAAAGzAIAgABLSXLbwvtvI2n0PLvKhU0TSWiEFSVS0qYLi4TNnUJjfBPN9yxmdR7PI4TKY5q6o83z7YAAAAAAAAB22nLq/R4lUZ0s71a1h4eq9Gmw9Xn9hvx2ZLq0g3KVHAy9L0Tk01UkMJrT5/HTCeD6FmOwylKyAABADAAAAyAwNICMRFAZAYAYAAQKEkh1BjaYYyAhmBkGgMsNOH0T6fzyqxacLdKQAABomgAA1XNcvZgvB9OuaUtDLIAgABADEQE2oYQloAaASYgBNhUGwBqgQTCAxADGSRNAQdNPK+38ne+/wpNygRgbCAIMDYAObKkcPJOP2s25vacigWZCQJhgQGgxgAMmiEAAEIAAMAMABEAAxkwEhMAAAEwiUvnvujx9r7/MtGKeYAmECE204M1PafqRForNU64T5/0CoWyd/h8XjtElBnmXL2AAAAAAAAACyeHV15rirp9NupXPnPN7nU78+y9/gzlSnISJzCmufs6tW6Jkkmg0SbPNv564vpY2fWBLVkAEaFAaAMmAAAEpBDDAggMAAYQBI3RoSyfFQqzS6ABMmwAJAieesd/g9/1eakQSXaCkwDRgBkwAqLKdML8/3+b5/SChRYGTZiNMIAACEYBohkI01OyBKRtgkkgAewEZJpEBiMSRgoMISHz9D1eXu3d4bjEAYHUkghqAxKADIaZOK5vUxfj99ybIoySAIDABoAACbIQAAAAEAGBBgAJAABMMQGACAMmgBEtVj0vR5W2dvjyNZXKNBMSBg0Otl2hSnJKgSg0z3k9LkOXp2fu8bmm5eMi35E5/dAAAAAAAAAOmWOtTxMVHSdCq56OPz69i6vLiac8RRaq7lzVkhW8yQDiaU3KDcsJpz0yPl9Wkz9Bx25CWCkzBQAYEtoAgYTAwBARJjUBKXxt0gCgMkCWIwS5DDTIYaQWkIr59n7fHttOZTSUlMWqU6NIhJBlNbTzFoyzl9LieT2FOlSOCIknRoAwMhmSkZAoCGlAAgIYESomiA1qkCUmmYwAYSkOUlKVR9efWezw+/wC3zTTJCBBgQYEAEYEwINso2w3h96g5u5U6G5ICAwICAwMCGkShkAAwAiGAJoJBswCA0BJAAYAoCS0kTOuOodPg6N08RU1pEg2AEBTy7ZpbEtmwgWrUGT83pdsuHI8da7McayevWAAAAAAAAAOufPtd+dN0zv8AbO5T4OHfk2w0OqWsqZPrDR4KlK2E6AE3NEqZcwpqDnve0OaDiTlhCDDBVIhBBobYSZgYlAHSiTYpDSpaQZJcoAJBtTQAhkSYGNabJVPWcnnHtE5CQJFJQHLQCQCDAwOkqnUTpYLSTUqVKIAONApLQBYFNJEoaW2hodIGtJA1ISSKRoQtECaQwNkbJbM0RTM3CBLmrue138/qTM7gJmJQKAgSBgYNDQgmMkcLzd7cd71pGaSqSJQGwwSBBDGEBUQ1AGgJwFNKQANgB8lIkpACKAzYlhktMgvG3vi7TRJvIQwqIEojBEZYDdY2SJogWxzSKnCpFPkOfu4viGysc6e8AAAAAAAAA7q+b0D0eU9WbxKcarVtms3eKkREOiopdtGs6kKFiWJxC2ljZFQt9pRPqZ1pwkTIaVSW0baUjbMDTAwAA3JkmBgEAZgAJtKZgBmmbTTRiIhIlqoE1Swsvx6bPO3x3AqulPolAyFfLZTmkxQktuokNdVpMq4kXCKnMoMrU6PV6tTmMQhA0SyTEjbl2ktjjTYlMCaEzBGiWhtCJbraU2QdEEjaYm4I6CYBU2s7QoBHQAWMNBBAYzBKaBMouG5jFUmgAOtqaNBiQ1WJ2bRIMCGTagTSISgCaQIACnJsSAA0zKbE0DaVPLo0PQODNw7Ntoi1NYi4GEiTbGkp4FsVrnNub7PWsT5Lm1jRXnGvWAAAAAAAAAO+vl9F9fi1UacPOzHOpQ68fRtybzpnpzDNURPJbSITgNNvMNpua43LVqVYEGlFKIANTEMDSwUCxBM01gAQIgDFMNgCMKQgNkkpBAkGxkNIG0QOJlLhsg0dhUOiuQqqHhOg0hCpAT7yqk3FUDPSompYKE8STbQ+G1zoN+W41wvtJkDXhvAzu6V9Pj0BURJVCWpQQmrBJ0DB62+IkFLNNTDAwJiKIElWprh3ZUkJbHmJAnIY8m0mANDlKIyEi6tWFp0SmiERKk0AQ1IFFeEtw4AEQBUpUAAksWm0m4DYmU1tEhTFAyggJpCdTDz+XJm7xO0bSiIFIJLUhjchhMscBRMlzFmqCbXWXZWIndpLyfl7IAAAAAAAAB1by1y+CDEuyU0z2t3X1Eil2u2Va7WV0dS84Q04JwDQYNBVZ3wHNtKzpwSHUgFOTBDZgYG0YG5MDGhMwUmaDYGGCKHU2gEoAAWAQBNg2AbdE2kAQin2z0DozuWprIQPS3QbZDTQixvOjm35fDc2459nrl64NwopZpU0sz156PTBWmah97j1cmlTONYyvo41KWsToMjUwkkjIE0nUNjaQgEggFAkpooomATHtdDrPW7w+xQPidY400hgHEJA6HWuR5tafG3bUtogjZtABgBLGhNBJYoZNpYSSmjIWmBpadpMzawMT7H0REkAQECRspobhyVTUi40LWLnRtp18vn5dlIwkQKZM0T80iR9zxOd2mZRvVbno6iSHkvL2wAAAAAAAAC2muynpS871+Ze6cejdCkPOMQ05aKsmpAOUiYtDyFirQmptRpy3P0WNiFnIpzKFVmBGMhmC2LBQKaSAAIMCGQkg2xSDAxIBLFoWNSCAmOCSmka00pxk6YV9eUnXNVJKDVmNIm00jVWTU6rTq+fQ86f0TrHmlEqpMVUcfLBktY0JmpHWI5JN5PWY17d2sTiZKw0kTbEijIUhsboGwgIAmwnHTKRkIVTIvPU+nBhtxNxIVKQAJAhgTYGq5PDeqzp1ufQlKKDSCEYGCQjMmocaYTeACZYGpLpka1LtIhtJv0n0BEcpwIYnlMdOOqZFBTgE2Guem9GUpWZFYnLZIpIG7IoCETphMgz/Hoss64qEMunjzZ1rJX1AAAAAAAAAFsr7GOkCsL59r6vFstMK1KokuaVU1ftLm1tqBaYFx6moDvaUSaZx2RUyKz6vXGQ9DgMagRSSBjWgxNsISwAAEthBoS2hJYgmKFCJyQGmaZpgYBIGxlOCnQJSk7HRShpJMYGkHEOMJiXCZ15nJXsVL2iXUPjQJt0tTHY0yI581ZqjAmwIlU+p9Ch1IjNEKl3kpsKlDhQw0tEpoqRg5NKG0hsFRRJ1NHOxN3pKGODCbUjYLEbEiK5fY5NNy7JU9Q9UNVDk0U0oagS1GaaFOYoCkSUYhaSm8DSDQ4w3LTHEAFDQCwYE6CUmxtDhSV8nMhZtqYsKsdmxSDSIFtqYZBIQW4RcTrnud8hz+xy66DDO7xAAAAAAAAALZadlHWkz6J4d11+FQ4as5+hb7cuu9fm8a466k6gxqADbCGigL6J5tQ8xw6a7HpmF3DwedGkSEMSmSagSBDAiAhKQGyYSAACOMDNNQg2kAhY1gsaQAjJAJJIUK507r5LS4NUl5pGGLEYBBFJJTOuY8vXL590UPVm9cmraT43Tngbc3FkXt5zZ14Os3G2xkh+iSlvuPRaLclmEOCdBQM1QlHSW5ddBhCIRA0CJGYqsT5wNJ6cLG5cTdTICJDaRhNTkDOa5GXIi5Fy5SUTJTaBQjAggCsGgBAaaFSXCXILIZIMAqWNQMCZQoTjRJk2gbjRgwEaXWRXB1Gw6xYUqQdo5WNUtBRABIcmNodfJk3J1WEbdlry8Bz+1xJ0hVnOnIAAAAAAAAAWy17OOoiLpc3bdPi8HyexEPT6/fx9q9DwqZz0DRpqJMGxkJAuXnSVUO464HzenDw9t2dSMlqyGbDlmkYlAAJMmGgNgomGmRmAM0S2aDBLkJEMwDSkEUElCMSAFJJk3rj6P9D5q2vFU6HeYAAYGBgmdEVknPTAvP8Af5zP01zRlENQKVATVRW9HlVXX4AaOkty4EdDzSjboPN9+Zz+gZALUC3KkkOVO3FLpm6S82sZOQ0TkCJpsmu15t17vLt7yJyBuJqBCDGTSxJEC8X4PUo8e6WqcY2CANSQyYYNNOggCVhIiAtELQPFsaTVKRsDRARJKiaJoIAyGpyAQNsUW4s9vN3Hs8ycXWNW1QBhBjUCWggiktRcunzZ5v0ThnpfV4/IYevzEdC1Wa68YAAAAAAAABbLTss+sOegeGy93j4z5/q1E9/W7eVsff4LNxbDISgUg2mGRwoY0tSMzjWo4vd5bD1VrcwICJAGBgTCBSAMNhI3lc6c3Ta8tveUysiFCVVmPRz2e1Fn0oXUaDdpaMRDAwAACSIwMhnbl9Jd/wAxYacj07isgIABmIAStBCJ0wTzfpudz9JRZDMQSMo1QGmsaXr+bhdHlprMDAlCTTnLbtuD6KTOsNaV+XQ2qUWh2SkDMZAtJLEiAEwCAgCHmvTz/RnoeBP153CVAAMCTAKGYKQkrBPP93kcfYXIoo1RMJikIaS5UmQgAJMakE0ozFCVQVKQkomzkDlNSkYAwAEMABAEkt3na7ePvfZ5DdTdtNtG2EgCmE0QAaAi4dfmvz/oppO7dXh4Xz+zUz0AecacQAAAAAAAABarTs46SF1t+fsPd5OK+f71Hn29hv5mud/zzLVyNypE0Y0uUC5eTplfD1n0mfVj/H7HMYewpWEwMMAEpMZgBENQO3l223n991eVbHPXzMCpZgMHtFYlSlpEL4bk9XgsPSYnpSpRVAZjAACAAYESnTh9Jej8xY6cy1ZAHJiAGBAkZA0tMA8v6aiz9JRZjMZiCRoNMFofPE28qq6vOi7ecp5k5db79vcs9W2O0o+XTVxvyPL28XHrQM90sJtSDTICaSwwAARCIktPN9I+j8/O053TNJYETFJqAxpIXOrdRhnnfR8bh6qlRmhgAAgSlokLGQLSKs+g15ux383otOW1rMhxlVbDos+zl8uzm57Go1CRNmhDkxEBAYGUZSHkhxO383bezwbi857ZCWCRkAYoRABtlQ8unzd5/wBJNnPee7xMC5fVrp6QGc3yAAAAAAAAAFqr7KdiefcacWv9XmYVwe/TZd/X9Pj7t2+Jmxnf1XTNOCCEj5UmbNw05dS89sf8/wBvluf11FhMCBQAnJEqTcWqHn1e3m6t3eLPfDysuJnvMTm0PtPOSarlUDNvVl0mtpnbJ+T2+R5/UNMmiLMABAAAEoGvF6U9H5mVpyIWrTkCcE6DwAEiMtqdfOnm/S1eXorWhsACQNPw49JYGrS83NOPre75rKt+NlwEGl306aNn0KSU4n2WNktaZ9y+xn3L6zEdIGCSAMQwAaABATQ18z0f6Pzk68HCElJAxOgBgpBmqdU1OH+d9FxeHrLVmWAAAQEQjEqZOp6vfi0bq8a/2wgxFcOBJHWZS1Pey6MbtqNn15xy+pw3L6Ta0JwCgAEQwIxgsnmkyst/O1jt+f7jTMhgQYACZgAIEukIh59Pm7zvo5BHoPs8bzzzejBnoIM7vAAAAAAAAAA7Cs9zvkeuL64uNOTBvL+oqo7L/q8fee3w+PeXVmkypXKbJhKuZmmGumVXNKlNMY8/3+cx9Rc2BgFFACcmgAoz0zr8XQOzyKTFQHVmnbUpVpCziyCamhK3zZRW4689Nz9s721nvF62XcvtCeo2wgmEAACSQenF6S9H5lnTljLSM4bQ+FkyxG8IhBWidvN/m/SV2fpKm1MAGghENQjUuTpa9fk632+JLri88Vnz1w6U3FaRFaW5IolpITaVnWV01WZduRcXu1GPoEMATCYACCYASxWvlejfS+dmvBxyFQAmg5cVGqQ4E2mpxHz/AKHi+f1zVrGQzGQACJWJy+TX+nx+z7vJoR1mNSs7sd