Осознанное неподчинение. Айра Чейлефф

Читать онлайн.
Название Осознанное неподчинение
Автор произведения Айра Чейлефф
Жанр Самосовершенствование
Серия
Издательство Самосовершенствование
Год выпуска 2015
isbn 978-5-9614-2426-3



Скачать книгу

id="n_1">

      1

      Paul Ricoeur, The Symbolism of Evil, trans. Emerson Buchanan (New York: Harper & Row, 1967).

      2

      Stefano Passini and Davide Morselli, “Authority Relationships between Obedience and Disobedience,” New Ideas in Psychology 27 (2009): 98–100.

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