The Cask. Freeman Wills Crofts

Burnley, ‘but before we discuss the matter excuse me a moment. I want to give my fellows some instructions.’

      He went out and called the men together. Sergeant Hastings and Constable Walker he retained, the rest he sent home in the car with instructions to return at eight o’clock in the morning. To Broughton he bade ‘Good-night,’ thanking him for his presence and help.

      When he re-entered the study Felix made up the fire and drew forward the whisky and cigars.

      ‘Thank you, I don’t mind if I do,’ said the detective, sinking back into his chair. ‘Now, Mr Felix, let us go over every one that knew about the cask being there.’

      ‘No one but myself and the carter, I assure you.’

      ‘Yourself, the carter, myself, and my man Walker—four to start with.’

      Felix smiled.

      ‘As far as I am concerned,’ he said, ‘I left here, as you appear to know, almost immediately after the arrival of the cask and did not return till after one o’clock. All of that time I was in the company of Dr William Martin and a number of mutual friends. So I can prove an alibi.’

      Burnley smiled also.

      ‘For me,’ he said, ‘I am afraid you will have to take my word. The house was watched by Walker from ten o’clock, and we may take it as quite impossible that anything could have been done after that hour.’

      ‘There remains therefore the carter.’

      ‘There remains therefore the carter, and, as we must neglect no possibilities, I will ask you to give me the address of the cartage firm and any information about the man that you may have.’

      ‘John Lyons and Son, 127 Maddox Street, Lower Beechwood Road, was the contractor. The carter’s name, beyond Watty, I don’t know. He was a rather short, wiry chap, with a dark complexion and small black moustache.’

      ‘And now, Mr Felix, can you not think of any others who may have known about the cask?’

      ‘There was no one,’ replied the other with decision.

      ‘I’m afraid we can’t assume that. We certainly can’t be sure.’

      ‘Who could there be?’

      ‘Well, your French friend. How do you know he didn’t write to others beside you?’

      Felix sat up as if he had been shot.

      ‘By Jove!’ he cried, ‘it never entered my head. But it’s most unlikely—most unlikely.’

      ‘The whole thing’s most unlikely as far as that goes. Perhaps you are not aware that someone else was watching the house last evening?’

      ‘Good God, Inspector! What do you mean?’

      ‘Someone came to the lane shortly after your arrival with the cask. He waited and heard your conversation with your friend Martin. When you and your friend left, he followed you.’

      Felix passed his hand over his forehead. His face was pale.

      ‘This business is too much for me,’ he said. ‘I wish to heaven I was out of it.’

      ‘Then help me to get you out of it. Think. Is there any one your friend knows that he might have written to?’

      Felix remained silent for some moments.

      ‘There is only one man,’ he said at length in a hesitating voice, ‘that I know he is friendly with—a Mr Percy Murgatroyd, a mining engineer who has an office in Westminster. But I don’t for one moment believe he had anything to say to it.’

      ‘Let me have his name and address, anyway.’

      ‘4 St John’s Mansions, Victoria Street,’ said Felix, on referring to an address book.

      ‘You might write it down, if you please, and sign it.’

      Felix looked up with a smile.

      ‘You generally write notes yourself, I should have thought?’

      Burnley laughed.

      ‘You’re very quick, Mr Felix. Of course it’s your handwriting I want also. But I assure you it’s only routine. Now please, think. Is there any one else?’

      ‘Not a living soul that I know of.’

      ‘Very well, Mr Felix. I want to ask just one other question. Where did you stay in Paris?’

      ‘At the Hotel Continental.’

      ‘Thanks, that’s everything. And now, if you will allow me, I will take a few winks here in the chair till it gets light, and if you take my advice you will turn in.’

      Felix looked at his watch.

      ‘Quarter-past three. Well, perhaps I shall. I’m only sorry I cannot offer you a bed as the house is absolutely empty, but if you will take a shakedown in the spare room—?’

      ‘No, no, thanks very much, I shall be all right here.’

      ‘As you wish. Good-night.’

      When Felix had left, the Inspector sat on in his chair smoking his strong black cigars and thinking. He did not sleep, though he remained almost motionless, only at long intervals rousing up to light another cigar, and it was not until five had struck that he got up and looked out of the window.

      ‘Light at last,’ he muttered, as he let himself quietly out of the back door into the yard.

      His first care was to make a thorough search in the yard and all the out-houses to ensure that the cask was really gone and not merely hidden in some other room. He was speedily satisfied on this point.

      Since it was gone it was obvious that it must have been removed on a vehicle. His next point was to see how that vehicle got in, and if it had left any traces. And first as to the coach-house door.

      He picked up the padlock and examined it carefully. It was an ordinary old-fashioned four-inch one. The ring had been forced open while locked, the hole in the opening end through which the bolt passes being torn away. Marks showed that this had been done by inserting some kind of lever between the body of the lock and the staple on the door, through which the ring had been passed. The Inspector looked round for the lever, but could not find it. He therefore made a note to search for such a tool, as if it bore marks which would fit those on the door, its evidence might be important.

      There was next the question of the yard gate. This opened inwards in two halves, and was fastened by a wooden beam hinged through the centre to the edge of one of the half gates. When it was turned vertically the gates were free, but when horizontally it engaged with brackets, one on each half gate, thus holding them closed. It could be fastened by a padlock, but none was fitted. The gate now stood closed and with the beam lying in the brackets.

      The Inspector took another note to find out if Mr Felix had locked the beam, and then stood considering. It was clear the gate must have been closed from the inside after the vehicle had gone out. It must have been opened similarly on the latter’s arrival. Who had done this? Was Felix lying, and was there some one else in the house?

      At first it seemed likely, and then the Inspector thought of another way. Constable Walker had climbed the wall. Why should not the person who opened and shut the gate have also done so? The Inspector moved slowly along the wall scrutinising it and the ground alongside it.

      At first he saw nothing out of the common, but on retracing his steps he noticed, about three yards from the gate, two faint marks of mud or dust on the plaster. These were some six feet from the ground and about fifteen inches apart. On the soft soil which had filled in between the cobble stones in this disused part of the yard, about a foot from the wall and immediately under these marks, were two sharp-edged depressions, about two inches long by half an inch wide, arranged with their longer dimensions in line. Someone had clearly used a short ladder.

      Inspector Burnley stood gazing at the