The Ragged Road to Abolition. James J. Gigantino II

tion>

      

      The Ragged Road to Abolition

      The RAGGED ROAD TO ABOLITION

      Slavery and Freedom in New Jersey, 1775–1865

      JAMES J. GIGANTINO II

      university of pennsylvania press

       philadelphia

      Copyright © 2015 University of Pennsylvania Press

      All rights reserved.

      Except for brief quotations used for purposes of review or scholarly citation, none of this book may be reproduced in any form by any means without written permission from the publisher.

      Published by

      University of Pennsylvania Press

      Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104-4112

       www.upenn.edu/pennpress

      Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper

      1 3 5 7 9 10 8 6 4 2

       Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data

      Gigantino, James J., II, 1983–

      The ragged road to abolition : slavery and freedom in New Jersey, 1775–1865 / James J. Gigantino II. — 1st ed.

      p. cm.

      Includes bibliographical references and index.

      ISBN 978-0-8122-4649-0 (hardcover : alk. paper)

      1. Slavery—New Jersey—History. 2. Slavery—New Jersey—Legal status of slaves in free states—History. 3. Anti-slavery movements—New Jersey— History. 4. New Jersey—History—1775–1865. I. Title.

      E445.N54G54 2014

      306.3´620974903—dc23

      2014012275

       To my parents, Lois and Jim Gigantino, who have helped make me the man I am today

      CONTENTS

       Introduction

       Chapter 1. Debating Abolition in an Age of Revolution

       Chapter 2. Sustaining Slavery in an Age of Freedom

       Chapter 3. Abolishing Slavery in the New Nation

       Chapter 4. Not Quite Free

       Chapter 5. Slavery, Freedom, and Citizenship in the New Republic

       Chapter 6. Slavery in Motion

       Chapter 7. Colonization and Gradualism’s Persistence

       Chapter 8. Creating a Free Life

       Chapter 9. Debating Slavery’s End

       Conclusion

       Notes

       Bibliography

       Index

       Acknowledgments

      State of New Jersey, county lines 1753–1824.

      Based on map created by R. Ryan Lash with information from Minnesota Population Center, National Historical Geographic Information: Pre-release Version 0.1, 2004.

Introduction

      This book is about the meaning of slavery and freedom in the United States. The setting, though unconventional, is central to American understandings of these two loaded terms. It follows the story of abolition in the North but reverses the usual narrative: slavery did not die after the Revolution, it sustained itself until the Civil War.

      In 1789, Catherine was born a slave in Hunterdon County, New Jersey. Like thousands of other slaves in the state, she worked daily for her master, John Hagaman, on his hundred-acre farm in Amwell. Cate, as her master called her, forged relationships with other slaves and in 1811 at twenty-two bore her first child, a boy named Bob, though the boy’s father remains unknown. Four years later, Catherine welcomed a daughter named Hannah. In 1840, Catherine moved with her master to neighboring Raritan without her children. Although the 1850 Census recorded her as a free woman, on February 16, 1856, Hagaman sold sixty-seven-year-old Catherine as a “slave for life” for twenty dollars to Charles Sutphin of Sommerville. After the sale, Hagaman, himself not much older than Catherine, moved with his son Dennis and daughter-in-law Mary to Joshua, Illinois, forty miles west of Peoria.¹

      Northern slaves like Catherine have usually been portrayed as peripheral to the overall development of the North and of the United States even though she experienced slavery decades after abolition’s enactment and in the midst of national debates over abolition and slavery’s westward expansion. Slavery in the North never attained the same position in the economy as it did in the Caribbean, the Chesapeake, or the Low Country since the North remained a society with slaves rather than a slave society. Indeed, early travel accounts describe New Jersey as both a place of few slaves and abundant opportunity. One visitor, Francisco de Miranda, the Spanish general, American ally, and future liberator of Venezuela, remarked during a 1783–1784 stay that he had not “encountered an individual who was ill clothed, hungry, sick, or idle.” Out of all the places he visited in America, de Miranda had never “seen any other place in which the people appear happier and on more of an equality” than New Jersey. According to him, New Jersey was truly the “Garden of America.”²

      Just six years after de Miranda’s visit, roughly 11,500 slaves lived in New Jersey. The “Garden of America” had more enslaved blacks than all of New England combined and almost the same slave to total population ratio as the much larger New York. Of course, the slave populations in most of the South easily outpaced New Jersey, though from 1790 to 1830 the state had more than twice as many slaves as Delaware. Additionally, some Jersey counties de Miranda likely visited heavily depended on slave labor. Bergen, for example, counted over 18 percent of its population as slaves at the time. Slaves likewise made up almost 15 percent of Somerset’s population, while Middlesex and Monmouth had a slave population of just under 10 percent.³

      While less than 1 percent of New England’s population remained enslaved by 1790, about 6 percent of the population in New York and New Jersey were slaves. Historians have glossed over these differences to argue that, while abolition came later in these two states (1799 and 1804 respectively) because of the larger slave population, the end result was the same: abolition produced a free black North that contrasted sharply with an enslaved South. The idea that abolition crept inevitably across the North after the Revolution leaves out most of the story and indeed many of its best chapters. As one historian put it, “slavery died hard” in the North, but the way it died illuminates far more than the fact that it died at all.⁴

      In this book I examine the long life of slavery in New Jersey and how whites and blacks adapted to the changes abolition brought. I see New Jersey and its gradual move toward abolition as part of a much wider web of interconnected relationships that crossed state and national borders as well as the Atlantic Ocean. By the end of the eighteenth century, freedom and slavery had been discussed from Boston to Barbados in the context of the Enlightenment and the American Revolution.